Scoreboard
Every claim Headwater has made, dated and logged the moment it was found. Nothing is removed if it turns out wrong — a claim is marked confirmed, refuted, or stays honestly unvalidated until something external exists to check it against.
1
unvalidated — nothing external exists yet to check against
1
refuted by our own later checking, kept on the record
CLAIM
DATE
STATUS
EVIDENCE
5 reviewer wallets found reviewing the same 6 agents (153–158)
Cross-agent review overlap, registry reads only, no chain scanning
2026-09-16
UNVALIDATED
Those 5 wallets on agents 153–158 are coordinating reviews
Wrong, and refuted by our own later checking rather than by anyone else. Four of the five raters are contracts, and their code exposes createGame, games and getRound. Each transaction carries one positive and one negative score, which is a winner and a loser. It is a game recording match results. Left on the record because deleting it would be the dishonest move.
2026-09-22
REFUTED
Agent 182’s 7,665 raters were all paid by its own owner, and all sent the money back
The owner sends 11.000000 MON, the wallet rates the agent 14 seconds later, and 6 seconds after that sends 10.934585768 MON back to the same owner. Checkable without us on any Monad explorer: out 0x2c7cebc273da93a5a66a41986ab36a2b6fe2ca96a57d928c58adb8600ced64d6, rating 0xf9f76e73916e1193d3453dbe6dc333b42888bb04dca50605514dd31d6b694661, back 0x62fad4d296f9d510a2b38ea8c09a3cdefc5bc57f39cb829fbfd674e1b01c9461. Confirmed externally: ProofLines measured the same thing from their own scan and publish the same 7,665.
2026-09-23
CONFIRMED
Only 1 of 7,824 rater relationships on this chain is a payment to a working agent made before the rating
We and ProofLines, from independent pipelines, both count 3 payments made before the rating, from 2 wallets. Corrected 2026-10-06: two of them, on agents 145 and 146, arrived two minutes before those agents were registered, so they paid for the wallets to exist, not for a service. The one left is agent 4. Rebuild it yourself with tools/measure-payments.mjs, which reads the same public endpoint and prints both counts.
2026-10-06
CONFIRMED